Transferring literature/shared reading to secure settings for potential therapeutic and psychosocial benefit to female prisoners with Personality Disorder who self-harm

 

The project will transfer the practical and therapeutic benefits of shared reading, as established by recently published research in the area of reading and mental health undertaken by members of the project team, in relation to female prisoners who deliberately self-harm.

 

The project establishes a partnership between the Ministry of Justice/Department of Health National Personality Disorder Team (NPDT) and The Reader Organisation (TRO), an outreach unit in collaboration with the School of English, University of Liverpool (UoL) and a nationally recognised centre for the promotion of reading as an intervention in mental health. TRO's ‘Get into Reading' project is a social inclusion programme based on shared reading and is distinguished from other reading therapies in emphasising the importance of serious, ‘classic' literature and its role in mediating experience and offering a model of human thinking and feeling. Published findings by the multidisciplinary project team, which derive from and theorise TRO's practical model and combine expertise in literature and health sciences, suggest that the act of reading together a literary text not only harnesses the power of reading as a cognitive process: it acts as a powerful socially coalescing presence, allowing readers a sense of subjective and shared experience at the same time. Related research (also conducted by a co-investigator) suggests that the inner neural processing of language when a mind reads complex literary formulations can galvanise existing brain pathways and influence emotion networks and memory function. These findings resonate with studies of female self-harm which stress the importance of interpersonal effectiveness, mindfulness of present experience, and reflective self-agency in reducing incidents of self-harm. The project would thus experimentally transfer recent research findings in the area of reading and health to a new health setting, thereby engaging a new community. In delivering, and evaluating the efficacy of, a humane and inexpensive service for mental health sufferers in female prisons (for whom treatments are otherwise often unavailable, economically costly or of uncertain benefit) the project has potential both to improve prisoner (mental) health and rehabilitation, and increase effectiveness of services by influencing policy planning and commissioning.

 

In close partnership with the NPDT, the project will establish weekly reading groups in two women's prisons where deliberate self-harm is of particular concern both as a significant health problem in its own right - it is one of the most common reasons for emergency admission to hospital - and as a risk factor for suicide. Drug intervention has proved unsuccessful in preventing repetition of self-harm - an externalised means of representing diffuse intrinsic distress rather than a symptom of somatic disorder or organic disease. Evidence is strongest for the effectiveness of psychosocial interventions which validate personal experience, develop conscious awareness of motivations and distortions and replace negative self-narrative with survival beliefs. The specific and original model of bibliotherapy developed by TRO has strong potential as an effective intervention in this context because of its recognized power to enhance social, mental and emotional well-being, (increasing confidence, concentration and self-esteem) and to elicit personal narrative in response to literary stories and poems, thus offering a conscious language in which individuals can recognise experience and ‘tell a new story' about themselves even as they become more able to articulate implicit ones. The impact of the knowledge transfer activity will be twofold, providing a humane, shared language for complex individual experience both to female prisoners who self-harm, and to health care professionals and prison authorities as an alternative or complement to diagnostic discourses which can contribute to self-stigma.